Chronically Dovish

How can you leave me standing
Alone in a world so cold?
--Prince

Despite doing next to nothing thus far, the Fed is currently perceived as hawkish in manners not seen since Paul Volcker. The popular narrative posits that the Fed will be raising rates 8-10 times this year to 'fight inflation,' with some rate increases possibly in the 50-75 bip range, as well as unwinding $1T or more of its balance sheet assets accumulated during more than a decade of quantitative easing.

This is...doubtful.

Evidence indicates that the Fed's so-called hawkishness never lasts longer than the marginal monetary policy action that triggers a crisis. As the graph above suggests, the tightening threshold that triggers a crisis has been declining in each successive policy cycle.

Why the declining threshold? Cheap credit created during monetary easing causes the system to lever up more so than the previous cycle. When asset prices fall during the subsequent tightening phase, balance sheets flip upside down quicker. Consequently, the financial system approaches insolvency at lower interest rate levels than before which, in turn, causes the Fed to ease off. Monetary policy never returns to where it was in previous cycles.

While the Fed might engage in hawk talk from time to time, its actions are chronically dovish.

The chart above suggests that the Fed will resume easing operations sooner rather than later--and at fed funds rate levels far lower than currently forecast.